Photo by Sean Locke via Stocksy
A new class action lawsuit has been filed against Facebook, alleging that it collects private medical information from well-respected cancer organizations.
"When you're searching private medical information, you don't realize it's being sent to Facebook," says Kiesel Law LLP partner Paul Kiesel. "If for example, I search for information on stomach cancer, they're going to know that either—God forbid—I have stomach cancer, or that I am interested in finding more information. Either way it is private medical information."
According to the suit, any site with a Facebook "like" button can potentially send browsing data to Facebook, possibly without the knowledge of the web developers. However, Kiesel Law LLP makes clear in its suit that many sites do not share data with Facebook. "For example, the websites for the Mayo Clinic and Johns Hopkins Medicine include a small Facebook icon on nearly every page, but do not permit Facebook to track user communications," the brief states.
As stated by a 2015 study on internet privacy cited in the complaint, medical information is the second most valuable type of data to be culled from users. After all, what motivates someone to spend cold hard cash better than their own health? "Look at the nightly news and you can see how much [the pharmaceutical industry is] spending on marketing," says Kiesel. "If they could target that marketing, that's enormously valuable to the business." According to the lawsuit, targeted ads produce 670 percent more clicks than non-targeted ads, and are twice as likely to make someone make a purchase.
Photo via Flickr user Spencer E Holtaway
Medical data is also valuable because it is so hard to get. Companies are not allowed to gather or share medical information without express authorization, because of the Health Insurance Portability & Accountability Act (HIPAA). Enacted in 1996, HIPAA sets ground rules for the medical industry that regulate the sharing of medical information.
Under HIPAA, medical information cannot be shared unless it is for a specific purpose. The purpose must be disclosed to the individual, with an expiration date, and with notification of the individual's right to revoke their authorization. The suit alleges that Facebook's data policies do not meet any of those guidelines.
Facebook has not disclosed what it uses this information for, but Keisel is optimistic that this lawsuit will bring it to light. "Discovery through litigation will bear out how it's used, whether it's banner ads, direct marketing, all that is possible. But what matters most is your right to privacy."
It is unclear whether cancer.org and the other wesbites named in the suit—cancer.net, melanoma.org, Adventist Health System, BJC Healthcare, the Cleveland Clinic, and University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center—were aware of the data mining done at the hands of Facebook. In an email to the Courthouse News Service, a Facebook representative said the suit "is without merit," and that they will defend themselves "vigorously."
Defense Secretary James Mattis is pitching his approach to defeat ISIS to the president, though details remain secret.Feb 27, 2017
A simple Excel spreadsheet revealed more secrets about “The Bachelor” to me than Chris Harrison ever could.Feb 27, 2017
Cosmetic surgery can trap people who suffer from body dysmorphia in an endless, frustrating, and dangerous quest for perfection.Feb 27, 2017
The Rohingya people of Myanmar have lived through mass gang rape, brutal beatings, and killings. A new UN report exposes the scale of atrocity suffered by its women and children.Feb 27, 2017
The Oscars may be more representative this year, but men still dominate 80 percent of non-acting nominations. Four women in the movie business tell us why industry prejudice remains so insidious.Feb 26, 2017
The Academy Award-winning 'Milk' screenwriter's new show, ‘When We Rise,’ follows three LGBTQ activists from 1970s gay liberation to 21st century marriage equality. Can the series unite a divided country?Feb 26, 2017
The Tonner Doll Company showcased the first trans doll based on Jazz Jennings, while other toy companies introduced the latest slew of nostalgic fare.Feb 25, 2017
At CPAC, Trump said that news outlets "shouldn't be allowed to use sources unless they use somebody's name." However, he allegedly used to speak to tabloids using a fake name to brag about himself.Feb 24, 2017
We spoke to trans teens about Donald Trumps recent"Dear Colleague" letter, which undermines the Obama administration's protections against discrimination against trans youth.Feb 24, 2017
A new exhibition curated by Hilton Als examines Alice Neel's portraits of her neighbors in Harlem.Feb 24, 2017